The yield is the risk-free rate plus expected inflation, an inflation risk premium, and a sovereign spread. The spread compensates for the hazard that the debt ratio produced by the yield implies, so the price is a fixed point, with a benign root, a crisis root, and a sunspot, a random event on which investors coordinate, that selects between the two where both exist.
The fiscal limit is the present value of the largest primary surplus the government can sustain. The paper reads that surplus from history, as the largest 10-year average each economy has sustained, and asks what announced capacity, ceiling, or growth increment, or what delivered primary balance, would eliminate the crisis equilibrium.
The line of sight
Introduction
- Establishes
- The setting: the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) projects federal debt held by the public at 100.6 percent of gross domestic product (GDP) for fiscal year 2026 and 120.2 percent for 2036, and names among the consequences “the risk of a fiscal crisis.” A crisis in the issuer of the world’s reserve asset differs from the episodes the literature has studied in three respects the model must represent: the convenience yield on Treasury debt, U.S. monetary policy as a driver of the global financial cycle, and debt denominated in the issuer’s own currency.
- Leads to
- In what model are those three features represented together?
2.1 Debt Dynamics
2.2 The Interest-Growth Differential and the Stationarity of the Debt Ratio
2.3 The Fiscal Limit as a Present Value
Fiscal capacity- Establishes
- The law of motion of the debt ratio, the two strands of literature on the interest-growth differential, and the fiscal limit as a present value: the largest sustainable primary surplus discounted at the real interest-growth differential, whose rate side, the year’s real marginal financing rate at a neutral policy rate, includes the spread being priced. The debt exceeds that limit where the growth-adjusted interest bill on the whole stock at that rate exceeds the capacity, as though the whole stock paid that rate from the year the limit is formed, while the law of motion reprices only the year’s share of the stock, one over its average maturity, at the year’s nominal marginal financing rate. The limit is unbounded while the real marginal financing rate at a neutral policy rate does not exceed trend real growth, and finite once it does.
- Leads to
- How does the market price debt that stands near such a limit?
2.4 The Price of Sovereign Debt
2.5 Multiplicity, the Crisis Zone, and the Sunspot
Price of the debt- Establishes
- The pricing fixed point. A root of the year’s pricing equation is a crisis root where the default hazard at that root exceeds half of its bound. An economy lies below its crisis zone where no crisis root exists, inside it where a crisis root stands beside a benign one and the market can coordinate on it, and beyond it where the crisis root is the only one. An economy is in crisis in a year it spends on the crisis equilibrium by either route, coordination or sole survival. A closed-form corner condition places the boundary in proportion to the fiscal capacity; the operative boundary, the one the first year of the paths obeys, lies 19 through 60 percentage points of GDP above it for the economies without a ceiling.
- Leads to
- Once the market is on the crisis equilibrium, what acts on the gap between the debt and the limit?
2.6 Monetary-Fiscal Regimes
2.7 Output, Inflation, Asset Prices, and Transmission
2.8 Central-Bank Backstops: Mandates and Record
Price of the debtFiscal capacity- Establishes
- Two courses a crisis can take, Leeper’s active-money regime (regime M) and active-fiscal regime (regime F): the gap between the debt and the limit is left to the primary balance in the first and to the price level in the second. Output, inflation, asset prices, and the transmission of a U.S. crisis to the other six economies. Central banks enter twice: as holders, whose share of the stock is financed at the policy rate, and as a backstop, a ceiling on the sovereign spread modeled from the Eurosystem’s Transmission Protection Instrument; its level and its conditions are assumptions. The ceiling is available while, in the year before, the primary balance, net of the automatic stabilizers, stood no more than a tolerance below its projected path and the debt did not exceed the fiscal limit, so it is withdrawn the year after an economy is first priced on a crisis root.
- Leads to
- On what values does the model run?
Calibration, Estimates, and the Baseline
Fiscal capacity- Establishes
- The capacity is taken from history rather than assumed: the largest 10-year average primary surplus each economy has sustained, in percent of GDP, with every receipt from abroad that a source identifies excluded; China’s, with no positive 10-year average on its record, is scaled from revenue. Debt is read net of the government’s financial assets. Parameters are of three kinds: values from the projections of the CBO and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and from published estimates; estimates the paper makes on other records, among them the fiscal capacities and the pass-through of U.S. long rates on the long-term interest rates of the Economic Outlook database of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD); and assumptions where no record identifies a value. The baselines of France and the United Kingdom are themselves on the crisis equilibrium, the United Kingdom’s in every year and France’s from 2032.
- On the macrohistory record the U.S. primary balance shows no response to lagged debt over 1871 through 2020; the interest-growth differential has been negative in 62 percent of years since 1950; and the response of the primary balance to debt, which the record separates from neither zero nor a positive value, is set to zero.
- Exhibits
- Table 1, initial conditions · Table 2 and Figure 1, the primary balance against lagged debt · Table 3, the response of the balance to debt · Table 4, the composition of the debt · Table 5, projection errors · Table 6, the differential and the pass-through · Tables 7 through 9, fiscal capacity by economy · Tables 10 through 12, the baseline beside the published projections
- Leads to
- Where does each economy stand against its crisis zone?
3.1 The Fixed Point and the Crisis Zone
3.2 The Rate at Which the Limit Is Discounted
3.3 Whether an Estimated Reaction Function Supplies a Debt Limit
3.4 The United States under the Two Regimes
Price of the debtFiscal capacity- Establishes
- In 2027 the United States, France, and Japan are inside their crisis zones, the United Kingdom is beyond its own, and Germany, Italy, and Canada lie below theirs. In the baseline and the central scenarios the crisis equilibrium requires that the fiscal limit be discounted at a rate that includes the spread being priced, except the United Kingdom in 2036. In the central scenarios, for the United States, France, the United Kingdom, and Japan, the crisis equilibrium does not rest on valuing the whole stock of debt at the limit’s real marginal rate from the year the limit is formed: the four keep crisis years under both regimes with the limit discounted along the path on which the stock reprices toward that rate, the U.S. crisis beginning in 2029 under regime M and in 2030 under regime F, against 2027 under both. Across the simulated paths, 51 percent carry a U.S. crisis year along that path, against 54 percent at the marginal rate. In the central scenarios Germany, with 2 crisis years under regime M at the marginal rate, has none along the repricing path, and Italy’s crisis years under regime M fall from 5 to 1. With the limit discounted in perpetuity at the rate on the stock, which reprices only the year’s share of the stock at the marginal rate, no economy has a crisis year in the baseline or the central scenarios, so that in those scenarios the crisis equilibrium rests on the discount rate’s converging to the marginal rate as the stock reprices. On none of three panels of the OECD’s Economic Outlook database is the cubic coefficient of the primary balance’s response to lagged debt, the coefficient on whose sign a debt limit built on that response depends, separated from zero, so the estimate supplies no debt limit, a largest debt at which the fitted balance covers the growth-adjusted interest bill. The results that follow are those of the limit discounted at the marginal rate: the U.S. crisis begins in 2027 under either regime and does not end within the 10-year horizon under either; the regimes differ in where the cost falls.
- Exhibits
- Figure 2, the pricing fixed point and the crisis zone · Tables 13 and 14, the limit formed without the spread · Tables 15 and 16, crisis years and shares of paths under four rate sides of the limit, in the central scenarios and across the simulated paths · Table 17, the U.S. capacity that eliminates the crisis equilibrium, at the marginal rate and along the repricing path · Table 18, the response of the primary balance to lagged debt with a cubic term · Table 19, the output loss against the record · Figure 3, U.S. paths under the baseline and the two regimes · Table 20, crisis outcomes by economy
- Leads to
- What reaches the other six economies?
3.5 Transmission
3.6 The Interest-Growth Differential along the Paths
Price of the debt- Establishes
- In the central scenarios France, the United Kingdom, and Japan are on the crisis equilibrium beside the United States in every year under both regimes; Germany and Italy are on it under regime M alone, in some years, and Canada in no year. On the deterministic paths of regime M the Eurosystem’s ceiling binds for France in 2027, for Italy in 2031 and 2032, and for Germany in 2034 and 2035, and is withdrawn the year after each is first priced on a crisis root; Italy is on the crisis equilibrium in 2032 through 2036 with the ceiling and in 2028 through 2036 without it. The U.S. interest-growth differential on the stock turns positive at the onset under regime M.
- Exhibits
- Table 21, the central-bank ceilings across the simulated paths · Figure 4, the 10-year yield of each economy · Figure 5 and Table 22, the differential, the primary balance, and the decomposition of the change in the debt ratio
- Leads to
- How much of this depends on the central values?
3.7 The Stochastic Simulation
3.8 Sensitivity
Price of the debtFiscal capacity- Establishes
- 10,000 paths that draw the capacity around its estimate, the other quantities the assumption tables mark as varied, and annual shocks. The share of paths on which each economy spends at least one year on the crisis equilibrium by 2036, with a bar on one scale from zero:
| Economy | Percent of paths | |
|---|---|---|
| United Kingdom | 80 | |
| France | 77 | |
| United States | 54 | |
| Japan | 44 | |
| Italy | 40 | |
| Germany | 24 | |
| Canada | 10 |
- Each economy has its own zone, and a crisis abroad does not require one in the United States: the crisis years of the United Kingdom and France rest on their own baselines and on the growth draw common to the eight economies as well as on the common sunspot. The United States spends at least one year on the crisis equilibrium on 54 percent of paths, the market coordinating on 21 percent and the crisis equilibrium arriving as the only root on the remaining 33, in 2027 on the paths that begin beyond the zone and later on the rest; a credit event occurs on 27 percent of paths. Conditional on a crisis, the median peak 10-year yield is 12.1 percent and the median debt ratio in 2036 is 141.7 percent of GDP. Trend growth is the largest single contributor to the variance of whether a crisis occurs; the fiscal capacity is the second. At a loss given default of 10 percent, the haircut of an illustration the paper cites, in place of 40, the U.S. share of paths with a crisis year is 32 percent and the share on which the market coordinates 1 percent. The shares are shares of simulated paths under stated ranges, not forecasts.
- Exhibits
- Figure 6, the distribution of the U.S. debt ratio and yield · Table 23, outcomes conditional on a U.S. crisis · Table 24, the variance between parameter draws and across shocks · Table 25, the level sensitivity · Table 26, the range of multiplicity against the dispersion of the limit · Table 27, deterministic variants · Figure 7, shares of variance
- Leads to
- Do faster growth or the central banks’ announced portfolio paths change the reading?
3.9 The AI-Adoption Productivity Path
3.10 Variant: The Announced Central-Bank Portfolio Paths
Price of the debtFiscal capacity- Establishes
- A sensitivity and a variant. Adding the Penn Wharton Budget Model’s projected contribution of generative AI to productivity growth to every trend path, with the fiscal capacity responding to growth, moves the share of paths with a U.S. crisis from 54 percent to 52. Applying the announced run-off of the central banks’ portfolios raises the crisis shares of Japan, France, Italy, Germany, and the United Kingdom and leaves the U.S. shares within a percentage point of the central calibration’s.
- Exhibits
- Table 28, the AI-adoption sensitivity · Table 29, the Bank of England’s gilt holdings under its announcement · Table 30, the central banks’ holdings on their announced paths
- Leads to
- Under what settings does the crisis equilibrium vanish?
Settings Under Which the Crisis Equilibrium Vanishes
Fiscal capacity- Establishes
- The paper solves for the capacity that eliminates the crisis equilibrium, rather than reading a requirement off the crisis paths, for every economy that reaches the crisis equilibrium in a central scenario. For the United States, no trend growth path of the central calibration makes the limit unbounded at the maximal crisis yield of the corner condition. The requirement is one figure for any announcement no later than the onset and rises with every announcement after it.
- Exhibits
- Table 31, the resolving capacity by announcement year · Figure 8 and Table 32, the resolving capacity over the drawn parameter sets · Figure 9, the years in which the crisis equilibrium exists against the announced capacity
- Leads to
- Is the capacity the only instrument that reaches a resolution?
The Resolution Map: Three Instruments
Price of the debtFiscal capacity- Establishes
- The same question solved for an announced capacity, an unconditional ceiling on the sovereign spread, and a permanent increment to trend growth. At the central calibration a ceiling eliminates the crisis equilibrium only where the baseline keeps a benign one, and in no case for the United Kingdom and France, while across the drawn parameter sets a ceiling eliminates the crisis equilibrium under regime M in 197 of the United Kingdom’s 888 sets with a crisis and in 229 of France’s 901. At the central calibration 18 of the 23 ceilings that eliminate a crisis equilibrium are still reached, the purchases absorbing a spread the hazard prices above them while no crisis root exists; every announced instrument must hold beyond the horizon; and a primary surplus delivered rather than announced can be smaller the later the year from which the crisis equilibrium is to vanish.
- Exhibits
- Table 33, the resolution map · Table 34 and Figure 10, the two instruments together · Table 35, the delivered primary surplus · Table 36, the swing against the revenue and expenditure base · Table 37, the map over the drawn parameter sets
- Leads to
- Has a consolidation of that size been sustained before?
4.2 The Requirement against the Historical Record
4.3 The Loss of the Safe-Asset Position and the Record of the Prior Suppliers
Fiscal capacity- Establishes
- The requirement set against the record of large primary surpluses, and against the fiscal history of the two economies that were dominant suppliers of a safe asset before the United States, each of which held a debt within its estimated fiscal backing after losing that position.
- Exhibits
- Table 38, the requirement against the record of large primary surpluses · Table 39, fiscal backing of the three dominant suppliers of a safe asset
- Leads to
- What limits the reading?
Limitations
Price of the debtFiscal capacity- Establishes
- The reading of the results is subject to 14 limitations.
- Leads to
- What, then, does the paper conclude?
Conclusion
Price of the debtFiscal capacity- Establishes
- The fiscal limit is proportional to the capacity. At the U.S. onset the coordination raises the limit’s financing rate from below trend growth to above it, the spread accounting for the larger part of the change and the loss of the convenience yield the smaller. In the baseline and the central scenarios the crisis equilibrium requires that the rate at which the limit is discounted include the spread being priced, except the United Kingdom in 2036, and that the discount rate converge to the limit’s real marginal rate as the stock reprices. In the central scenarios, for the United States, France, the United Kingdom, and Japan, the crisis equilibrium does not require that the whole stock be valued at the marginal rate from the year the limit is formed. Which U.S. policy authority adjusts decides the outcome of the U.S. crisis but, at the central calibration and the capacities the record shows, not whether it occurs; for Germany and Italy, with the limit discounted at the marginal rate, it decides the occurrence as well. The cost of the U.S. crisis falls on output under both regimes, and in addition on the debt ratio under regime M and on the price level under regime F. The capacity is where a resolution would come from, and it is not the only instrument that reaches one. The multiplicity is conditional on two quantities the record does not pin for a G7 sovereign, the dispersion of the fiscal limit and the loss given default.
- Leads to
- Where does China stand, its spread administered rather than set by a marginal investor?
China
- Establishes
- China is modeled in the computation and stands outside the set of economies the paper studies. Its sovereign spread is administered by a state-directed holder base under capital controls rather than set by a marginal investor, so the coordination the paper measures does not price for it. Priced as a market issuer it is on the crisis equilibrium for 6 of the 10 years under regime M.
- Exhibits
- Table 40, China under three readings
- Appendices
- Appendix A, the assumptions of the model: Tables A.1 through A.13, each parameter with its value, unit, basis, and treatment in the stochastic simulation · Appendix B, supplementary results: Table B.1, the central scenarios against the product of the loss given default and the bound on the default hazard; Table B.2, spreads and yields at the start of the horizon; Table B.3, the crisis outcomes of Table 23 on the crisis paths with no drawn U.S. credit event; Table B.4, the transmission coefficients re-estimated on a long-run target